Proposed Amendment to IIROC By‑law No. 1 Regarding Director Term Limits

19-0060
Type: Administrative Notice> Request for Comments
Distribute internally to:
Legal and Compliance
Senior Management

Contact:

Doug Harris
Vice President, General Counsel and Corporate Secretary
Telephone:
Email:

On March 27, 2019, the Board of Directors (the Board) of the Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada (IIROC) approved for publication for comment proposed amendments to subsection 5.3(2) of IIROC By-law No. 1 (the By-law) to change the way in which Director term limits are calculated.

The amendment is subject to final Board, regulatory and Member approvals.  IIROC intends to seek Member approval of the amendment at its Annual General Meeting in September 2019.

Description of the Proposed Amendment

Subsection 5.3(2) of the By-law provides that, with the exception of the President, a Director may be elected to serve four consecutive terms in office but shall not be eligible to be elected to serve a fifth consecutive term.

Currently, if a Director is appointed (under Section 5.6 of the By-law) to replace a Director who has left during his or her two-year term, the new Director assumes the same term as the departing Director.  For example, if a departing Director leaves after 18 months, the new Director’s first term will be the remaining six months (the stub term).

Under subsection 5.3(2), the stub term counts towards the new Director’s four-term limit. The new Director in our example therefore has an effective term limit of six years and six months.

We propose a By-law amendment that would exclude the stub term from the term limit calculation. 

If the amendment were in force, the term limits for the current Directors would be as follows:

Director

Terms Appointed/ Elected
(Assuming Amendment)

Current Term Limit
End Date

New Term Limit
End Date

Brian Heidecker (Independent)

Sept 2011 – 2 yr term

Sept 2013 –  2 yr term

Sept 2015 – 2 yr term

Sept 2017 – 2yr term

2019

Same

Paul Allison (Chair) (Dealer)

Oct 2013 – 11 mo term1

Sept 2014 – 2 yr term

Sept 2016 – 2 yr term

Sept 2018 – 2 yr term

Sept 2020 – 2 yr term

2020

2022

Jean-Paul Bachellerie (Dealer)

Sept 2013 –  1 yr term2

Sept 2014 – 2 yr term

Sept 2016 – 2 yr term

Sept 2018 – 2 yr term

Sept 2020 – 2 yr term

2020

2022

James Donegan (Independent)

Sept 2012 – 2 yr term

Sept 2014 – 2 yr term

Sept 2016 – 2 yr term

Sept 2018 – 2 yr term

2020

Same

Ed Iacobucci (Independent)

Sept 2012 – 2 yr term

Sept 2014 – 2 yr term

Sept 2016 – 2 yr term

Sept 2018 – 2 yr term

2020

Same

Catherine Smith (Independent)

Sept 2012 – 2 yr term

Sept 2014 – 2 yr term

Sept 2016 – 2 yr term

Sept 2018 – 2 yr term

2020

Same

Gerry O’Mahoney (Independent)

Sept 2013 – 1 yr term3

Sept 2014 – 2 yr term

Sept 2016 – 2 yr term

Sept 2018 – 2 yr term

Sept 2020 – 2 yr term

2020

2022

Holly Benson (Dealer)

Jan 2015 – 7 mo term4

Sept 2015 – 2 yr term

Sept 2017 – 2 yr term

Sept 2019 – 2 yr term

Sept 2021 – 2 yr term

2021

2023

Luc Paiement (Dealer)

Sept 2016 – 2 yr term

Sept 2018 – 2 yr term

Sept 2020 – 2 yr term

Sept 2022 – 2 yr term

2024

Same

Michèle Colpron (Independent)

Sept 2017 – 2 yr term

Sept 2019 – 2 yr term

Sept 2021 – 2 yr term

Sept 2023 – 2 yr term

2025

Same

Luc Fortin (Marketplace)

Jan 2018 – 19 mo. term5

Sept 2019 – 2 yr term

Sept 2021 – 2 yr term

Sept 2023 – 2 yr term

Sept 2025 – 2 yr term

2025

2027

Lucie Tedesco (Independent)

Sept 2018 – 2 yr term

2026

Same

Jos Schmitt (Marketplace)

Sept 2018 – 2 yr term

2026

Same

Rationale for the Proposed Amendment

Because of the application of current subsection 5.3(2), four Independent Directors and two Dealer Directors (including the current Board Chair) are reaching their term limits in 2020.

The provision has therefore had the unintended effect of reducing the extent to which the terms of the members of IIROC’s are “staggered”.  Staggering of Director terms promotes both Board renewal and succession planning.

Specifically, the proposed amendments will:

  • ensure that all Directors have a term limit of at least eight years
  • extend the terms of certain Directors who would otherwise reach their term limit in September 2020 to promote continuity and orderly Board succession.

The Mutual Fund Dealers Association of Canada (MFDA) takes the same approach to term limits in its By-law.  Subsection 3.3.2. of the MFDA By-law provides that

  • A Public Director shall be eligible to serve for only 2 successive terms of 3 years which shall include any shorter term as may have been fixed by the Board of Directors in accordance with this By-law, but shall exclude any portion of a term of office in respect of a vacancy filled pursuant to Section 3.5. (emphasis added)

Section 3.3.3 of the MFDA By-law is to the same effect for MFDA Industry Directors.  Section 3.5 of the MFDA By-law is similar to Section 5.6 of the IIROC By-law.6   

Approval Process

The amendment is subject to final Board, regulatory and Member approvals.

IIROC staff will present a summary of the comments received to the IIROC Board before seeking final IIROC Board approval of the amendment.

Under subsection 2(a)(i) of Appendix A to IIROC’s Recognition Orders, prior CSA approval is also required for any change to the By-law.

If IIROC staff receive final Board approval and CSA approval, we intend to seek Member approval of the amendment at IIROC’s Annual Meeting in September 2019.

We anticipate that the proposed amendments will be made effective on the date of Member approval.

Impact of the Proposed Amendments

IIROC has determined that the proposed amendment will only result in changes to the routine internal processes, practices and administration of IIROC and will have no material impact on investors, issuers, members, registrants or the capital markets in any province or territory of Canada.

Request for Public Comment

Comments are requested on the proposed amendment.  Comments should be in writing and delivered by May 6, 2019 to:

  • Doug Harris
    Vice President, General Counsel and Corporate Secretary
    Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada
    Suite 2000, 121 King Street West
    Toronto, Ontario M5H 3T9
    email: [email protected]

A copy should also be provided to the Recognizing Regulators by forwarding a copy to:

  • Market Regulation
    Ontario Securities Commission
    Suite 1903, Box 55
    20 Queen Street West
    Toronto, Ontario M5H 3S8
    e-mail: [email protected]

Commenters should be aware that a copy of their comment letter will be made publicly available on the IIROC website at www.iiroc.ca.

Attachments

A black-line copy of subsection 5.3(2) of IIROC By-law No. 1, reflecting the proposed amendment, is attached.

  • 1Replacing Marianne Harris as a Dealer Director.
  • 2Replacing Robert Blanchard.
  • 3Replacing Michael Boychuk.
  • 4Replacing Sheldon Dyck.
  • 5Replacing Nick Thadaney.
  • 6The MFDA recently proposed amendments to its By-law that change this wording, but otherwise are to the same effect:  Bulletin #0778-P, Proposed Amendments to MFDA By-law No. 1 (March 14, 2019).

Other Notices associated with this Consultation:

Welcome to CIRO.ca!

We have a new look! You can find the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO) at CIRO.ca with our fresh look and feel.

You can now find new publications published by CIRO since January 1, 2023 on CIRO.ca. If you are looking for past notices or bulletins published by MFDA or IIROC, you can find those on our legacy websites. Enforcement related content will continue on those websites as well.

You can now find previous Annual Reports and Enforcement Reports on CIRO.ca, along with Halts and Resumption, and our ePublications sign up (for all previous MFDA and IIROC subscriber lists).

We will continue moving items off MFDA and IIROC in 2023/2024. Stay tuned for future updates.